Is this required, or is it just how we've always done it?
HD and PD · Checked 14 Jul to 11 Nov 2026 · One-page sheet for the binder
In short
- Required means a statute, a regulation, a document the regulation adopts, or a CMS payment rule like the QIP.1,2,3,4,5,6,7
- CMS guidance is how CMS tells surveyors to read and enforce the rules, including its own deadlines. It isn't the regulation, but surveyors work from it.4
- Professional guidelines recommend. KDOQI's target of 1.4 per session (three times a week) sits above the 1.2 floor the regulation sets.3,4,8
- House practice is everything else. Once it's written into policy, a surveyor holds you to it.3,4
The four levels, with an example of each
- CMS guidanceSurvey guidance and CMS memosFor example: One method for drawing the Kt/V samples4
- Professional guidelineKDIGO, KDOQI and other guideline bodiesFor example: Target spKt/V 1.4 per session, three times a week8
- House practiceThe facility's own choiceFor example: A monthly chemistry panel
Written into your policy, a house practice is read against your floor like any other rule.3,4
The detail
Find where the rule lives. A federal requirement lives in a statute, a regulation, or a document the regulation adopts by reference. Survey guidance explains how surveyors check those rules, QIP rules decide payment, and professional guidelines recommend; none of them is the regulation itself.3,4,7,8 Everything else is facility policy, and a policy line that cannot name its source is a habit.
- Applies to
- HD and PD
- Checked
- 14 Jul to 11 Nov 2026
- Covers
- Federal Medicare rules for dialysis facilities, and where professional guidelines and house practice sit beside them
- Doesn't cover
- State licensure rules; accrediting organization standards; legal interpretation
One example on each level
One-page sheet for the binder| Level | What it says | Clock | How much it binds | Applies to | Where it says so | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Statute | During the coordination period an employer group health plan pays first and Medicare second. | 30 monthsFrom the first month of ESRD entitlement, or earlier if the person would have been entitled had they applied | Requiredstatute, for payment | HD and PD | Where it says so · applies to | |
| Regulation | Deliver an HD Kt/V of at least 1.2, or meet an equivalent professionally accepted standard for adequacy.“a hemodialysis Kt/V of at least 1.2” | None | Requiredregulation, to stay certified | HD (in-center and home) | Where it says so · applies to | |
| Regulation by incorporation | Follow the CDC's 2001 recommendations for preventing infections among chronic hemodialysis patients, except its hepatitis C screening. The regulation adopts the document by reference, so its testing schedule binds as written.The incorporated document is written for chronic hemodialysis. How a PD program applies it is set by facility policy. | None | Requiredregulation by incorporation, to stay certified | In-center HD | Where it says so · applies to | |
| CMS program rule | A facility whose QIP total performance score falls below the minimum has its Medicare payments reduced by up to 2 percent for the payment year. | Each payment year scores performance from two years earlier | RequiredCMS program rule, for payment | HD and PD | Where it says so · applies to | |
| CMS survey guidance | One method for drawing the Kt/V samples, which every staff member follows: pre and post samples at the same treatment, the post sample after slowing or stopping the pump. Home HD patients are taught the same way. | Each adequacy drawFrom the scheduled adequacy treatment | CMS guidanceCMS survey guidance | HD (in-center and home) | Where it says so · applies toAppendix H (Rev. 246), V518Applies to: HD (in-center and home) | |
| Professional guideline | Target an spKt/V of 1.4 per session for patients treated three times a week, with a minimum delivered spKt/V of 1.2.Written for thrice-weekly HD; it doesn't set a PD target. | None | Professional guidelineprofessional guideline | In-center HD | Where it says so · applies toKDOQI HD Adequacy 2015, Guideline 3.1Applies to: In-center HD | |
| House practice | A monthly chemistry panel. No regulation, survey guidance or guideline sets a monthly clock for the panel itself.Calcium is the exception to watch: QIP's Hypercalcemia reporting measure counts the patient-months a calcium value is reported (through payment year 2028). | Monthly, by facility customFrom the facility's lab calendar | House practicehouse practice | HD and PD | No outside source | Where it says so · applies toNo outside sourceApplies to: HD and PD |
| House practice, once written into policy | A house practice written into facility policy has to be followed: the medical director must ensure the policies on admissions, patient care, infection control and safety are adhered to. A surveyor reads your policy against your floor, even where no outside rule set the clock. | None | Requiredregulation, to stay certified | HD and PD | Where it says so · applies to |
Where it can break
Break A: Between professional guidelines and facility policy
A guideline target is written into policy as a federal requirement, or the federal floor is treated as the goal.
Who feels it: Staff measured against the wrong line, and the patients whose care that line shapes.
How it shows up: For HD adequacy the regulation sets Kt/V 1.2 and KDOQI targets 1.4. A policy that reads "1.4, required by CMS" sends staff after a requirement that does not exist; one that treats 1.2 as the goal stops short of the evidence.
What catches it: A policy line that names its source and its level shows which it is.
Break B: Between facility policy and practice on the floor Fails silently
The practice outlives its source, or never had one.
Who feels it: Staff asked to defend it, and the leaders deciding whether it can change.
How it shows up: "We've always done it this way": a practice nobody can source, kept or dropped on habit rather than on a rule or the evidence.
What catches it: A practice that traces to a policy line, and a policy line that traces to its level, can be sourced. A line with no outside clock is the facility's own decision, kept or changed through its own policy review. State rules aren't covered here.
The path
The path as a list, step by step
- 1
Statute
Authority to set standards → CMS
- 2
Regulation
The regulation's own pointer to professional standards → Guideline bodies
- 3
Professional guidelines
Break A: Recommendations to adopt, or not → Facility leadership
- 4
Facility policy
Break B, fails silently: What staff are taught → Nursing staff
- 5
Practice on the floor
What surveyors observe → State survey agency
- 6
Survey
What each step's record proves, and what it doesn't
| Step | Who | Proves | Doesn't prove | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Statute | CongressChanges by act of Congress | Congress authorized the benefit and its programs. | Any particular clinical practice. Statutes set authority, not lab schedules. | |
| 2. Regulation | CMSChanges by rulemaking | A practice is federally required when the text says so. | That a stricter local practice is required. | RequiredThe dose rule itself allows "an alternative equivalent professionally-accepted clinical practice standard for adequacy of dialysis" (494.90(a)(1)).3 |
| 3. Professional guidelines | Guideline bodiesUpdated by the guideline body | What current evidence recommends. | That CMS requires it. | |
| 4. Facility policy | Facility leadershipThe facility's review cycle | What staff are expected to do here. | Which lines are federal, which are guidelines, and which are local choice, unless each line says so. | House practiceFacility policy is local. It must meet the regulation; anything beyond that is the facility's choice. |
| 5. Practice on the floor | Nursing staffEvery treatment | What happens. | Why it happens, or whether anything still requires it. | My readEvery practice should trace to a policy line, and every policy line to a level above. |
| 6. Survey | State survey agencyPeriodic survey | Whether practice met the regulation on the day, as the surveyor assessed it. | That everything not cited is required. Survey guidance explains the regulation; it is not the regulation. | CMS guidanceState survey agencies survey for CMS under the federal survey and enforcement framework (42 CFR Part 488), using Appendix H.4,11 |
What this page can't tell you
- What your state requires. State licensure rules can add requirements beyond the federal ones; this page covers federal Medicare rules only.
- Whether an older binder is current. Survey guidance moved into Appendix H in May 2026 and was formally issued in August; binders may still quote the 2008 interpretive guidance, which CMS no longer posts.4,12
Next
Sources
- Social Security Act 1862(b)(1)(C), 42 U.S.C. 1395y(b)(1)(C)42 U.S.C. 1395y(b)(1)(C) · read at the issuer · checked 10 Nov 2026
- 42 CFR 411.16242 CFR 411.162 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
- 42 CFR Part 494 (§§ 494.20-494.180)42 CFR Part 494 · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
- State Operations Manual, Appendix H: Guidance to Surveyors, ESRD Facilities (Rev. 246)CMS Pub. 100-07, Transmittal 246 (issued, effective and implemented 2026-08-17), SOM Appendix H Parts I-III · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
- CDC MMWR 2001;50(RR-05)—Recommendations for Preventing Transmission of Infections Among Chronic Hemodialysis PatientsMMWR 2001;50(RR-05):18-28 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
- 42 CFR 413.177 and 413.17842 CFR 413.177(a); 413.178 · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
- ESRD QIP PY2026 fact sheetCMS ESRD QIP PY2026 fact sheet · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
- KDOQI Clinical Practice Guideline—Hemodialysis Adequacy (2015 Update)Am J Kidney Dis. 2015;66(5):884-930 · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
- Medicare Improvements for Patients and Providers Act of 2008 (MIPPA), sec. 153Public Law 110-275; SSA sec. 1881(h) · read at the issuer · checked 26 Jul 2026
- ISPD—prescribing high-quality, goal-directed peritoneal dialysis (Brown et al.)Perit Dial Int. 2020;40(3):244-253 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
- 42 CFR Part 48842 CFR Part 488 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
- CMS memo QSO-26-09-ESRD: Relocating and Revising CMS Surveyor Guidance for ESRD FacilitiesCMS QSO-26-09-ESRD (2026-05-15), effective immediately; attachment: Advance Copy of Appendix H · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
https://middlemolecule.com/connections/required-or-habit/