Middle Molecule Find

Topics › Required or habit

Is this required, or is it just how we've always done it?

HD and PD · Checked 14 Jul to 11 Nov 2026 · One-page sheet for the binder

In short

  • Required means a statute, a regulation, a document the regulation adopts, or a CMS payment rule like the QIP.1,2,3,4,5,6,7
  • CMS guidance is how CMS tells surveyors to read and enforce the rules, including its own deadlines. It isn't the regulation, but surveyors work from it.4
  • Professional guidelines recommend. KDOQI's target of 1.4 per session (three times a week) sits above the 1.2 floor the regulation sets.3,4,8
  • House practice is everything else. Once it's written into policy, a surveyor holds you to it.3,4

The four levels, with an example of each

  1. RequiredA statute, a regulation, a document it adopts, or a CMS payment ruleFor example: Deliver an HD Kt/V of at least 1.23,4
  2. CMS guidanceSurvey guidance and CMS memosFor example: One method for drawing the Kt/V samples4
  3. Professional guidelineKDIGO, KDOQI and other guideline bodiesFor example: Target spKt/V 1.4 per session, three times a week8
  4. House practiceThe facility's own choiceFor example: A monthly chemistry panel

Written into your policy, a house practice is read against your floor like any other rule.3,4

More ink, more binding. Each example is a line from this site.

The detail

Find where the rule lives. A federal requirement lives in a statute, a regulation, or a document the regulation adopts by reference. Survey guidance explains how surveyors check those rules, QIP rules decide payment, and professional guidelines recommend; none of them is the regulation itself.3,4,7,8 Everything else is facility policy, and a policy line that cannot name its source is a habit.

Applies to
HD and PD
Checked
14 Jul to 11 Nov 2026
By
John Cruz, RN
Covers
Federal Medicare rules for dialysis facilities, and where professional guidelines and house practice sit beside them
Doesn't cover
State licensure rules; accrediting organization standards; legal interpretation

One example on each level

One-page sheet for the binder

How much the 8 lines below bind

  • 5 Required
  • 1 CMS guidance
  • 1 Professional guideline
  • 1 House practice
Every rule on a dialysis floor sits on one of these levels. Only the first four bind a facility to stay certified or be paid; the rest explain, recommend or choose.
LevelWhat it saysClockHow much it bindsApplies toWhere it says so
Statute
During the coordination period an employer group health plan pays first and Medicare second.
30 monthsFrom the first month of ESRD entitlement, or earlier if the person would have been entitled had they applied
Requiredstatute, for payment
HD and PD
Where it says so · applies to
Regulation
Deliver an HD Kt/V of at least 1.2, or meet an equivalent professionally accepted standard for adequacy.“a hemodialysis Kt/V of at least 1.2”
None
Requiredregulation, to stay certified
HD (in-center and home)
Where it says so · applies to
42 CFR 494.90(a)(1)
Appendix H (Rev. 246), V544Applies to: HD (in-center and home)
Regulation by incorporation
Follow the CDC's 2001 recommendations for preventing infections among chronic hemodialysis patients, except its hepatitis C screening. The regulation adopts the document by reference, so its testing schedule binds as written.The incorporated document is written for chronic hemodialysis. How a PD program applies it is set by facility policy.
None
Requiredregulation by incorporation, to stay certified
In-center HD
Where it says so · applies to
CMS program rule
A facility whose QIP total performance score falls below the minimum has its Medicare payments reduced by up to 2 percent for the payment year.
Each payment year scores performance from two years earlier
RequiredCMS program rule, for payment
HD and PD
Where it says so · applies to
CMS survey guidance
One method for drawing the Kt/V samples, which every staff member follows: pre and post samples at the same treatment, the post sample after slowing or stopping the pump. Home HD patients are taught the same way.
Each adequacy drawFrom the scheduled adequacy treatment
CMS guidanceCMS survey guidance
HD (in-center and home)
Where it says so · applies to
Appendix H (Rev. 246), V518Applies to: HD (in-center and home)
Professional guideline
Target an spKt/V of 1.4 per session for patients treated three times a week, with a minimum delivered spKt/V of 1.2.Written for thrice-weekly HD; it doesn't set a PD target.
None
Professional guidelineprofessional guideline
In-center HD
Where it says so · applies to
House practice
A monthly chemistry panel. No regulation, survey guidance or guideline sets a monthly clock for the panel itself.Calcium is the exception to watch: QIP's Hypercalcemia reporting measure counts the patient-months a calcium value is reported (through payment year 2028).
Monthly, by facility customFrom the facility's lab calendar
House practicehouse practice
HD and PD
No outside source
Where it says so · applies to
No outside sourceApplies to: HD and PD
House practice, once written into policy
A house practice written into facility policy has to be followed: the medical director must ensure the policies on admissions, patient care, infection control and safety are adhered to. A surveyor reads your policy against your floor, even where no outside rule set the clock.
None
Requiredregulation, to stay certified
HD and PD
Where it says so · applies to

Where it can break

Each break sits at a handoff on the path below. A silent one gives no signal when it happens.

  1. Break A: Between professional guidelines and facility policy

    A guideline target is written into policy as a federal requirement, or the federal floor is treated as the goal.

    Who feels it: Staff measured against the wrong line, and the patients whose care that line shapes.

    How it shows up: For HD adequacy the regulation sets Kt/V 1.2 and KDOQI targets 1.4. A policy that reads "1.4, required by CMS" sends staff after a requirement that does not exist; one that treats 1.2 as the goal stops short of the evidence.

    What catches it: A policy line that names its source and its level shows which it is.

  2. Break B: Between facility policy and practice on the floor Fails silently

    The practice outlives its source, or never had one.

    Who feels it: Staff asked to defend it, and the leaders deciding whether it can change.

    How it shows up: "We've always done it this way": a practice nobody can source, kept or dropped on habit rather than on a rule or the evidence.

    What catches it: A practice that traces to a policy line, and a policy line that traces to its level, can be sourced. A line with no outside clock is the facility's own decision, kept or changed through its own policy review. State rules aren't covered here.

The path

Statute to the treatment floor. Each lane is a role. StepRecordCan break hereFails silently The same path is listed below.
The path as a list, step by step
  1. 1

    Statute

    Congress · Changes by act of Congress

    Authority to set standards → CMS

  2. 2

    Regulation

    CMS · Changes by rulemaking

    The regulation's own pointer to professional standards → Guideline bodies

  3. 3

    Professional guidelines

    Guideline bodies · Updated by the guideline body

    Break A: Recommendations to adopt, or not → Facility leadership

  4. 4

    Facility policy

    Facility leadership · The facility's review cycle

    Break B, fails silently: What staff are taught → Nursing staff

  5. 5

    Practice on the floor

    Nursing staff · Every treatment

    What surveyors observe → State survey agency

  6. 6

    Survey

    State survey agency · Periodic survey

What each step's record proves, and what it doesn't
6 steps, in order.
StepWhoProvesDoesn't proveRule
1. Statute
CongressChanges by act of Congress
Congress authorized the benefit and its programs.
Any particular clinical practice. Statutes set authority, not lab schedules.
RequiredPart 494 names the 1972 amendments as its statutory basis (494.1); MIPPA section 153 is the QIP's authority.3,9
2. Regulation
CMSChanges by rulemaking
A practice is federally required when the text says so.
That a stricter local practice is required.
RequiredThe dose rule itself allows "an alternative equivalent professionally-accepted clinical practice standard for adequacy of dialysis" (494.90(a)(1)).3
3. Professional guidelines
Guideline bodiesUpdated by the guideline body
What current evidence recommends.
That CMS requires it.
Professional guidelineKDOQI Hemodialysis Adequacy 2015 Update; ISPD 2020 recommendations.8,10
4. Facility policy
Facility leadershipThe facility's review cycle
What staff are expected to do here.
Which lines are federal, which are guidelines, and which are local choice, unless each line says so.
House practiceFacility policy is local. It must meet the regulation; anything beyond that is the facility's choice.
5. Practice on the floor
Nursing staffEvery treatment
What happens.
Why it happens, or whether anything still requires it.
My readEvery practice should trace to a policy line, and every policy line to a level above.
6. Survey
State survey agencyPeriodic survey
Whether practice met the regulation on the day, as the surveyor assessed it.
That everything not cited is required. Survey guidance explains the regulation; it is not the regulation.
CMS guidanceState survey agencies survey for CMS under the federal survey and enforcement framework (42 CFR Part 488), using Appendix H.4,11

What this page can't tell you

  • What your state requires. State licensure rules can add requirements beyond the federal ones; this page covers federal Medicare rules only.
  • Whether an older binder is current. Survey guidance moved into Appendix H in May 2026 and was formally issued in August; binders may still quote the 2008 interpretive guidance, which CMS no longer posts.4,12

Next

Sources

  1. Social Security Act 1862(b)(1)(C), 42 U.S.C. 1395y(b)(1)(C)42 U.S.C. 1395y(b)(1)(C) · read at the issuer · checked 10 Nov 2026
  2. 42 CFR 411.16242 CFR 411.162 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
  3. 42 CFR Part 494 (§§ 494.20-494.180)42 CFR Part 494 · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
  4. State Operations Manual, Appendix H: Guidance to Surveyors, ESRD Facilities (Rev. 246)CMS Pub. 100-07, Transmittal 246 (issued, effective and implemented 2026-08-17), SOM Appendix H Parts I-III · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
  5. CDC MMWR 2001;50(RR-05)—Recommendations for Preventing Transmission of Infections Among Chronic Hemodialysis PatientsMMWR 2001;50(RR-05):18-28 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
  6. 42 CFR 413.177 and 413.17842 CFR 413.177(a); 413.178 · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
  7. ESRD QIP PY2026 fact sheetCMS ESRD QIP PY2026 fact sheet · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
  8. KDOQI Clinical Practice Guideline—Hemodialysis Adequacy (2015 Update)Am J Kidney Dis. 2015;66(5):884-930 · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026
  9. Medicare Improvements for Patients and Providers Act of 2008 (MIPPA), sec. 153Public Law 110-275; SSA sec. 1881(h) · read at the issuer · checked 26 Jul 2026
  10. ISPD—prescribing high-quality, goal-directed peritoneal dialysis (Brown et al.)Perit Dial Int. 2020;40(3):244-253 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
  11. 42 CFR Part 48842 CFR Part 488 · read at the issuer · checked 14 Jul 2026
  12. CMS memo QSO-26-09-ESRD: Relocating and Revising CMS Surveyor Guidance for ESRD FacilitiesCMS QSO-26-09-ESRD (2026-05-15), effective immediately; attachment: Advance Copy of Appendix H · read at the issuer · checked 11 Nov 2026